Fish Or Fish Oil?
Via Eating Fabulous comes this article discussing a study regarding getting omega-3s from fish versus fish oil. Here is the study abstract.
Here’s the conclusion:
From the article:
The 16-week study with healthy premenopausal women showed that the increases in red blood cell levels of the omega-3 fatty acids eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) were similar after taking supplements or eating oily fish.From the abstract:
These findings suggest that the consumption of equal amounts of EPA and DHA from oily fish on a weekly basis or from fish-oil capsules on a daily basis is equally effective at enriching blood lipids with n–3 FAs. [omega-3 fatty acids]
There is also a brief discussion of the pollutant issue that many people talk about in reference to fish.
However, a number of studies and experts on both sides of the Atlantic have report that the benefits of omega-3, protein, and essential vitamins and minerals from oily fish outweigh the risks of pollutants. Moreover, British researchers reported in 2006 that pollutant levels were falling among many fish.
I double up, using both fish oil and cod liver oil and also having fish once or twice a week, though not always the oily fish. I usually eat tilapia because it’s much cheaper than wild-caught salmon. The n-3 levels are lower, but as I’ve mentioned before, I take 1 tbsp each of fish and cod liver oils, so I think I’m A-OK. I also eat sardines in water 3-5 times a week and canned wild salmon here and there. There’s no question that omega-3s are vitally important, but now you can rest assured that regardless of where you get them, so long as they are the long-chain fatty acids EPA and DHA, your body is making good use of them
If you enjoyed this post, share it on StumbleUpon or Health Ranker (or both!)
- Other Stuff You'll Enjoy:
- How Fish Oil Does Its Work
- Fish Oil’s Anti-Inflammatory Properties
- Cod Liver Oil Protects Against Type 1 Diabetes
- Omega-3’s Protect Against Parkinson’s
- Does a Western Diet Low In Omega-3s Promote Depression?
Print This Post
Filed in Know Your Fats 7 Comments so far
Subscribe


sarena on 07 Jan 2008 at 3:43 pm #
And just yesterday I asked about FATS!
Scott Becker on 08 Jan 2008 at 12:50 am #
Very nice blog! This is very interesting. So if I understand you right - the fish helps with red blood cell levels. My girlfriends blood has an iron deficiency, I wonder if oily fish would be beneficial.
The only problem would be - how do I get her to eat fish.
Scott Kustes on 08 Jan 2008 at 7:50 pm #
Sarena, Might be awhile before I can work on the article you asked for. I have two big projects I’m working on along with just starting a new job. Perhaps that’s something you could put together and guest post?
Scott, what I read from it is that they used red blood cells to measure the levels of the omega-3 fatty acids, EPA and DHA. I don’t know that it has anything to do with iron deficiency or that it can help. Perhaps someone else has some ideas there. As for getting her to eat fish, white fish like tilapia, while lower in n-3 than something like salmon, are pretty mild fish. Maybe starting her on something like that to get her used to the idea before springing the good stuff like salmon on her?
Cheers
Scott
Scott on 16 Jan 2008 at 2:24 am #
Scott, Sorry that it took me so long to get back to you. I do appreciate your response and your help. I’m still not sure about the omega-3 levels, but I know eating fish can’t be bad and I got her to try tilapia this past weekend- It’s a start - thanks again!
susan allport on 22 Jan 2008 at 2:37 pm #
Thought you might be interested in this omega-3 video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIgNpsbvcVM
Carla Tremblay on 12 Jul 2008 at 5:51 pm #
Why do you supplement with both cod liver oil and fish oil? Why not just one? Also, does the brand of oil matter?
Thanks in advance!
Scott Kustes on 13 Jul 2008 at 10:43 am #
Carla, I only use CLO now. I was using both because CLO has the naturally occurring vitamins A&D, while fish oil has more omega-3 per serving. But I’ve cut back some on my supplementation, especially since I don’t take in any sources of major omega-6s like vegetable oils or grains. My meats are now grass-fed/pastured, so that’s not a source of unnatural quantities of omega-6 either.
Hope that helps
Scott